Family Law Arbitration, Mediation and other forms of Non-Court Dispute Resolution

The Family Procedure Rules (FPR) in England and Wales provide a comprehensive code of practice for family law cases.

These rules ensure fairness and accessibility in family court proceedings. They aim to streamline the process, reducing the emotional and financial burden on families and the rules have recently changed to put more emphasis on mediation, family law and other forms of non-court dispute resolution (NCDR).

Non-court dispute resolution (NCDR) offers an alternative to Court proceedings. It aligns with the overarching objectives of the FPR, providing a more private and controlled outcome. The FPR rules have, for a long time, encouraged mediation as method of avoiding Court proceedings. In fact, couples were obligated to at least attend a Mediation Information & Assessment Meeting (also know as MIAM) to assess if mediation was a suitable alternative to Court.

There have been discussions about making mediation a mandatory step before the Courts become involved however, the change of rules has not made mediation mandatory but has made it clear that NCDR must be considered not only before Court proceeding but throughout the duration of the case. Advisors, including family law solicitors, are expected to promote and educate their clients on the NCDR alternatives to Court and should Court intervention be deemed necessary, the Court will be asking before and throughout proceedings, why NCDR is not appropriate.

This is a huge shift to try and encourage families in dispute to avoid, where possible, traditional Court proceedings

Understanding the Family Procedure Rules (FPR)

The Family Procedure Rules (FPR) in England and Wales are a set of regulations that govern family law proceedings and the FPR plays a crucial role in family law cases. It provides a clear and comprehensive framework for dealing with family disputes.

The FPR is divided into various parts, each dealing with different aspects of family law. These include matters related to children, financial remedies, domestic abuse, and international issues, among others. The rules are designed to be flexible, allowing for the unique circumstances of each case.

The FPR is underpinned by a set of overarching objectives. These include:

  • Ensuring that cases are dealt with justly and at a proportionate cost.
  • Saving expense and ensuring that cases are dealt with expeditiously and fairly.
  • Dealing with the case in ways which are proportionate to the nature, importance, and complexity of the issues.
  • Ensuring that parties are on an equal footing.
  • Enforcing compliance with rules, practice directions, and orders.
  • Promoting welfare of children involved in family law disputes.

Non-Court Dispute Resolution (NCDR) Under the FPR

Non-Court Dispute Resolution (NCDR) is a now key aspect of the Family Procedure Rules (FPR). The FPR encourages parties to consider NCDR methods before resorting to court proceedings. This is in line with the overarching objectives of the FPR, which aim to deal with cases in a way that is proportionate to their nature, importance, and complexity.

NCDR methods include collaborative divorce, private financial dispute resolution (FDR), family law arbitration and mediation. These methods offer a range of benefits, including greater control over the process and outcome, privacy, and often, a more amicable resolution. They can also be more cost-effective and less time-consuming than traditional court proceedings.

The FPR provides a legal framework for these NCDR methods. For instance, it sets out the requirement for a Mediation Information and Assessment Meeting (MIAM) before certain applications can be made to the court. This encourages parties to consider mediation before resorting to litigation.

The use of NCDR methods aligns with the FPR’s emphasis on the welfare of children. These methods often result in less acrimonious disputes, which can be beneficial for children involved.

Collaborative Divorce: A Cooperative Approach

Collaborative divorce is a form of NCDR that involves parties and their lawyers working together to reach a settlement. This process is underpinned by a commitment to avoid court proceedings. The parties sign a ‘participation agreement’ which sets out their commitment to the process and to finding a solution that works for everyone.

The process involves a series of ‘four-way’ meetings between the parties and their lawyers. These meetings provide a forum for open discussion and negotiation. The aim is to reach a mutually acceptable agreement that meets the needs of all parties, including any children involved.

The FPR supports the use of collaborative divorce. It recognises the benefits of this approach, including the potential for a more amicable resolution and the preservation of relationships, particularly where children are involved.

Private Financial Dispute Resolution (FDR): Efficiency and Confidentiality

Private Financial Dispute Resolution (FDR) is another form of NCDR. It involves a neutral third party, often a retired judge or experienced family lawyer, who helps the parties to reach a settlement on financial matters. This process is private, confidential and can be more efficient than court proceedings.

The FDR process involves a meeting where each party presents their case. The neutral third party then provides an indication of how a court might deal with the issues. This ‘early neutral evaluation’ can help parties to reach a settlement.

The FPR recognises the role of private FDR in family law disputes. It provides a framework for this process, including the requirement for parties to consider FDR before certain applications can be made to the court.

Family Law Arbitration: A Binding Alternative

Family Law Arbitration is a form of NCDR where a neutral third party, the arbitrator, makes a decision on the dispute. This decision, known as an ‘award’, is legally binding. Family Law Arbitration can be used for a wide range of family law issues, including financial matters and disputes about children.

The arbitration process is flexible and can be tailored to the needs of the parties. It is private and confidential, and the parties have a say in the choice of arbitrator. The decision of the arbitrator is final and can be enforced by the courts if necessary.

The FPR recognises the role of arbitration in family law disputes. It provides a legal framework for this process, including the recognition and enforcement of arbitration awards.

Mediation: Facilitating Amicable Solutions

Mediation is a form of NCDR where a neutral third party, the mediator, helps the parties to reach a settlement. The mediator does not make a decision but facilitates discussion and negotiation between the parties. Mediation can be used for a wide range of family law issues, including disputes about children and financial matters.

The mediation process is flexible and can be tailored to the needs of the parties. It is private and confidential and can result in a more amicable resolution. The outcome of mediation is not legally binding but can be made so by applying to the Court for a consent order.

The FPR strongly encourages the use of mediation in family law disputes. It sets out the requirement for a Mediation Information and Assessment Meeting (MIAM) before certain applications can be made to the Court. This encourages parties to consider mediation before resorting to litigation.

The Benefits and Challenges of NCDR

Non-Court Dispute Resolution (NCDR) methods offer a range of benefits. However, they also present certain challenges and considerations. Understanding these can help parties make informed decisions about the best way to resolve their disputes.

NCDR methods can be more cost-effective and efficient than traditional court proceedings. They offer greater control over the process and outcome and can result in more amicable resolutions. This can be particularly beneficial where children are involved. However, NCDR methods also require a willingness to cooperate and negotiate, which may not be possible in all cases.

The Family Procedure Rules (FPR) provide a legal framework for NCDR methods. They encourage parties to consider these methods before resorting to court proceedings. However, the FPR also recognises that court intervention may still be necessary in certain cases.

Limitations and Considerations of NCDR Methods

While NCDR methods offer many benefits, they also present certain challenges and considerations. One of the key considerations is the need for cooperation and negotiation. NCDR methods require a willingness to engage in open and honest discussion, which may not be possible in all cases.

Another consideration is the enforceability of agreements reached through NCDR. While family law arbitration awards are legally binding, the outcomes of mediation and collaborative divorce are not. However, they can be made legally binding by applying to the court for a Consent Order.

Finally, NCDR methods may not be suitable for all types of disputes. For instance, they may not be appropriate in cases involving domestic abuse or where there is a significant power imbalance between the parties. In such cases, court intervention may be necessary to ensure fairness and protect the rights of the parties.

Seek Legal Advice

The increasing emphasis on Non-Court Dispute Resolution methods reflects a shift towards more efficient, cost-effective, and amicable solutions for divorcing and separating couples and it’s a shift that the team of family law solicitors at Tyrer Roxburgh fully support. Court action may sometimes be required but it’s expensive and stressful so if it can be avoided, it should be avoided. If you are facing a divorce and need help with the divorce application and negotiating a financial settlement and / or arrangements for children please get in touch. We guide you through the entire process including the NCDR options.

We pride ourselves on being friendly and approachable so if you need advice from one of our friendly solicitors, please do get in touch by calling 0208 889 3319 or via one of the options below.

The first introductory call is free and enables you to outline your circumstances and for us to explain how we can help. Our team are friendly and approachable and are always happy to answer your questions.

If you have a question about our services, please use our online form to send us an email.

If you need to speak with someone you will always receive a friendly welcome if you telephone between the hours of 9am-5pm but if we are closed, you can  request a callback. We will call you back as near to your requested time as possible.

Related Posts

Grandparents Rights: Do Grandparents have a right to see Grandchildren?

Grandparents Rights: Do Grandparents have a right to see Grandchildren? For most grandparents, grandchildren are a blessing to be loved and cherished, for children, grandparents are an extremely important part of their life. Extended family that can help to build, [...]

2024-05-25T13:15:26+01:00
Go to Top